Barnsley vs Sheffield Wednesday Prediction, Betting Tips & Preview
Featured OfferBetAhoyBet £10 Get a £10 Free BetClaim Free Bet →Code ALLABOARD10 – Place qualifying bet within…
Barnsley
Sheffield WednesdaySouth Yorkshire derbies never need much selling, but this one comes with an extra layer of intrigue that makes it genuinely compelling beyond the tribal stuff. You have got a Barnsley side drowning near the bottom of League One, desperate for anything that feels like a lifeline, up against Sheffield Wednesday who have just rediscovered some swagger under a new manager and are hunting down the automatic promotion spots. Survival versus ambition, fear versus momentum. That is a proper football match right there.
What makes it even more interesting is the recent history of both clubs in this division. Wednesday were supposed to be blowing through League One this season, fresh ownership, better squad, the whole package. They wobbled, changed manager again, and now they are trying to find their footing at exactly the right moment. Barnsley, meanwhile, brought back a manager who took them up before, and it simply has not clicked. Friday night under the lights at Oakwell, with everything on the line for the hosts. You could not script it.
This South Yorkshire Derby takes place at Oakwell, Barnsley’s compact and atmospheric ground in the heart of the town, in what is a League One fixture that carries enormous weight for both clubs but for very different reasons. The home supporters will be desperate to see their side drag themselves back into safety territory, while Wednesday’s travelling end will be in fine voice after last weekend’s convincing result.
Barnsley have a few headaches to manage, with the most significant blow being the absence of Cameron McGeehan through suspension. The captain and top scorer picked up his fifth yellow card of the season against Wigan, so he misses out at the worst possible time. Alongside that, the Reds are dealing with a handful of other absences.
Sheffield Wednesday have far fewer problems to worry about and may well name an unchanged side from the team that put three past Plymouth Argyle last weekend. Their squad has been significantly bolstered by returning players in recent weeks.
Daniel Stendel’s hand is fairly well forced at Barnsley. Patrick Kelly walks straight into the midfield to replace McGeehan, most likely alongside Luca Connell and Daniel Johnson. Reyes Cleary and Vimal Yoganathan offer support from wider areas, with Makenzie Kirk the most likely candidate to lead the line ahead of Rylan Brownlie and Amani Richards.
Barnsley: Slicker; Okedina, Gale, Kay, Larkeche; Johnson, Connell; Yoganathan, Kelly, Cleary; Kirk
Dave Challinor has very little reason to tinker after a performance that emphatic. Joe Lumley starts in goal behind a back three of Bernard, Liam Cooper and Sil Swinkels. Barry Bannan and Callum Slattery should again provide the creative thread behind Davis Keillor-Dunn, who has found the net in each of his last three outings and will be the man Barnsley fear most.
Sheffield Wednesday: Lumley; Bernard, Cooper, Swinkels; Valery, Heskey, Mitchell, Gray; Slattery, Bannan; Keillor-Dunn
Barnsley’s form is alarming by any measure. From 13 League One matches this season they have picked up just nine points, with only two wins to show for their efforts and eight defeats. The last time they won in the third tier was back in early September, meaning they have gone nine league games without a victory. They came into the Wigan game with a bit of spirit following a draw against Oxford and back to back cup wins, but could not turn that into something meaningful as Fraser Murray’s opener was cancelled out before Jensen Weir won it for Wigan late on. Three points from safety with only goal difference separating them from bottom side Bromley, the pressure on Stendel and his players is immense.
Sheffield Wednesday’s story is a more complicated one. They flew out of the blocks at the start of the season, looked every inch a team that would run this division, then ran into a rough patch across October and November that cost Henrik Pedersen his job. Two draws under the caretaker kept them ticking over but that fast start was starting to feel like a distant memory. Dave Challinor came in and his first two games brought cup defeats against lower league opposition, which was not exactly the ideal start. Last Saturday though was a different story entirely. A 3-0 win at Hillsborough, Billy Mitchell opening the scoring and Keillor-Dunn and Di’Shon Bernard putting the gloss on it in the closing stages, was the kind of performance that suggests the squad has responded well to the new voice in the dressing room.
The contrast in momentum could not be starker. Barnsley look like a side that cannot find a way to win regardless of the opposition, while Wednesday are carrying the energy and belief that comes with a big, convincing result going into a derby. That matters more than people give it credit for.
South Yorkshire derbies between these two are rarely dull and rarely kind to whichever side goes in as the underdog. The meetings between Barnsley and Sheffield Wednesday tend to be fiercely contested with plenty riding on them, and historically the away side has often found it difficult to impose themselves at Oakwell when the home crowd is in full voice. The problem for Barnsley right now is that the crowd being roused has not translated into results on the pitch, and Wednesday have shown in recent meetings that their quality tends to tell over the course of ninety minutes when they are firing properly.
Wednesday look the clear bet here. They are in better shape, have a striker in red hot form, and are facing a Barnsley side missing their captain and best player through suspension. The angle for this one is backing Wednesday to win comfortably, with Keillor-Dunn at the heart of things and a home side that is running short on defensive organisation and confidence.
Leaning towards no on this one. Barnsley have genuine attacking threats but without McGeehan pulling strings and with confidence at rock bottom, finding the net against a Wednesday back three that kept a clean sheet last week feels like a stretch. Wednesday’s defence looks well set and the Reds’ recent goal return has not been convincing enough to back them to score here.
Derby nights at Oakwell have a habit of producing a few bookings, and with Barnsley’s players having everything to prove in front of their own fans against their local rivals, there will be no shortage of full blooded challenges. Expect at least three or four cards across the ninety minutes, with the home side more likely to pick them up as frustration builds if Wednesday go ahead early.
Sheffield Wednesday were dominant territorially last weekend and should enjoy a lot of the ball again here against a Barnsley side that tends to sit deep when confidence is low. Wednesday getting bodies forward and working the channels behind a struggling back four should generate a healthy corners count. Going over eight corners in the match looks a reasonable shout, with Wednesday taking the majority.
Under 2.5 goals feels slightly cautious given Wednesday’s attacking quality and Barnsley’s defensive fragility, but the more appealing call is over 2.5. Wednesday scored three last week, Keillor-Dunn is in the kind of form where he almost always creates or scores something, and even if Barnsley nick a goal, Wednesday should have enough firepower to get to three across the ninety minutes.
Davis Keillor-Dunn is the standout pick here without much hesitation. Three goals in three consecutive appearances for the Sheffield Wednesday forward, playing behind a midfield that creates chances and against a Barnsley defensive unit that has been leaking goals all season. He is the in form striker in this fixture and at a price he represents good value as first scorer.
Sheffield Wednesday to win 2-0. Wednesday have the quality to keep Barnsley at arm’s length without McGeehan and with their defensive structure looking increasingly solid. Keillor-Dunn getting one and Wednesday wrapping it up with a second goal feels like the most likely outcome given the respective trajectories of these two clubs right now.
| Market | Selection |
|---|---|
| Match Result | Sheffield Wednesday to Win |
| First Goalscorer | Davis Keillor-Dunn |
| Both Teams To Score | No |
Keillor-Dunn opening the scoring fits perfectly with a Wednesday win and a clean sheet, given his current run of form and Barnsley’s lack of firepower without their suspended captain.
Sheffield Wednesday come into this in a completely different headspace to their opponents. A new manager who got an immediate positive response from his squad, a striker who cannot stop scoring, and a defensive unit that is finally looking organised again. Barnsley are three points adrift of safety, missing their best player, and have not won a league game in two months. The occasion will lift the Oakwell faithful and Stendel will set his team up to be hard to beat, but against this quality of opponent on current form, that may not be enough.
Prediction: Barnsley 0-2 Sheffield Wednesday
£5 FREE AT VERSUS!
No Deposit Needed
Get £5 completely free to use on a trade at VERSUS! No deposit. No card. Just enter your email address to get instant access to the offer.