Exeter City vs Rotherham United Prediction, Betting Tips & Preview

Featured Offer

BetAhoy

Bet £10 Get a £10 Free Bet

Claim Free Bet →

Code ALLABOARD10 – Place qualifying bet within 7 days of registration (Min £10 at odds of EVS+). 2 x £5 free bets awarded once qualifying bet settles (18+). Full T&C’s Apply. #ad

Exeter City

vs

Rotherham United

KickoffSaturday 3 October 2026, 3:00pm

VenueSt James Park Exeter

CompetitionEnglish League 2

TV ChannelSky Sports+

Exeter City are in a rough spot right now. Four league goals in eight games, four winless league outings on the spin, and a solitary league victory back in August that feels like a long time ago. The Grecians came down from League One hoping to hit the ground running and bounce straight back, but this has been a painful opening to the season. Matt Taylor’s side look short of confidence and shorter still of cutting edge up front.

Rotherham United are not exactly flying, but they have a very different feel about them at the moment. Unbeaten in their last four across all competitions, picking up a road win at Northampton and showing some resilience to come from behind and draw with Crewe last weekend, the Millers look like a team that is slowly finding its feet under Alex Bruce. Four points and a calmer mood heading into this one. The contrast between these two sides right now is stark.

Exeter City vs Rotherham United Match Details

This League Two fixture takes place at St James Park in Exeter, with both sides nine rounds into their first seasons back in the fourth tier following relegation. Exeter sit 21st with six points, Rotherham are in 13th with ten, and there is already a sense that the gap between them could tell the story of the afternoon.

Team News

Exeter are carrying a few injury concerns that have not helped their already fragile attacking options, while Rotherham arrive with their own lengthy casualty list to manage.

• Ed Turns remains absent for Exeter and is yet to play a single minute this season
• Sonny Cox has missed the last four matches through injury and looks unlikely to feature
• Danny Rose has been given the job up front in recent weeks as Taylor looks to find a solution in attack
• Rotherham are without Lenny Agbaire, Klaidi Lolos, George Sebine and Jamie Jellis through injury
• Fabio Tavares and Ewan Otoo were both unavailable last weekend and their status for this one is uncertain

Predicted Lineups

Matt Taylor looks set to stick with the shape he has been working with, with Charlie Cummins and Jake Doyle-Hayes holding midfield and Gwion Edwards, Reece Cole and Ethan Sutherland providing support behind Danny Rose. There is not a huge amount of depth to call upon, so wholesale changes feel unlikely.

Alex Bruce may well name an unchanged side if Tavares and Otoo remain unavailable. Dominic Iorfa is expected to continue in the back three alongside Denzel Hall and Sonny Aljofree despite the own goal he put through last weekend, and Paul Mullin leads the attack after getting off the mark with a leveller against Crewe.

• Exeter: Bycroft; Samuel, Taylor, Fitzwater, Woodhouse; Cummins, Doyle-Hayes; Edwards, Cole, Sutherland; Rose
• Rotherham: Eyestone; Hall, Iorfa, Aljofree; Nemane, Spence, Ashley, Austerfield, Buyabu; Bradshaw, Mullin

Recent Form

Exeter’s numbers make for grim reading. One win from eight league games, four goals scored across the entire campaign, and a run of four consecutive league matches without finding the net. Their last league outing was a 1-0 defeat away at Bristol Rovers, where Fabrizio Cavegn’s goal just past the hour mark was enough to send them home empty handed. Before that, a draw with Tranmere and a Trophy exit on penalties to Cheltenham. It is not a team that looks like it is about to click into gear.

Rotherham’s recent run tells a better story. A 3-3 draw at home to Salford showed some vulnerability at the back, but wins and draws have followed, including that 1-0 road victory at Northampton. The Trophy win away at York City on penalties added a bit of momentum, and while the Crewe draw last weekend was not a thriller, coming from behind to get a point shows a side with some grit about them. Paul Mullin getting on the scoresheet matters too. A striker finding his feet is always a boost.

The form trajectory is heading in opposite directions. Exeter are struggling to score, struggling to win, and playing in front of a home crowd that must be getting anxious. Rotherham are compact, unbeaten in four, and travelling with a little bit of belief. These are not the ideal conditions for a Taylor bounce back performance.

Head-to-Head Record

These two clubs have not crossed paths all that regularly, but there is an extra storyline here worth noting. Matt Taylor, Exeter’s current gaffer, is of course the man who managed Rotherham United before taking the St James Park job. Facing your former club always adds a layer of edge to a fixture, and Taylor will be desperate to claim the three points against the side he used to call home.

The head to head record between the clubs does not throw up any dominant pattern in favour of either side, and with both starting life fresh in League Two this season, previous meetings in different divisions carry limited weight. What matters more right now is the current state of both squads, and on that measure, Rotherham hold the edge.

Key Stats

• Exeter have scored just four league goals in eight games, an average of half a goal per match
• The Grecians have failed to score in their last four league outings
• Rotherham are unbeaten in their last four games across all competitions
• Paul Mullin has scored four league goals since his summer arrival, bringing genuine threat in the final third

Exeter City vs Rotherham United Betting Tips

This fixture sets up pretty neatly for a low scoring Rotherham win. Exeter simply cannot buy a goal at the moment, and Rotherham’s defensive solidity over the last few weeks suggests they will be hard to break down. The value angles are in the markets that reward caution and Rotherham’s steady improvement.

Over and Under Goals Prediction

Under 2.5 goals looks like the play here. Exeter have not scored in four consecutive league games, and Rotherham’s recent defensive shape has been fairly tight. A low scoring affair feels right, with under 2.5 goals the sensible call.

Cards Prediction

With Exeter under pressure at home and chasing a result they desperately need, frustration could creep in, particularly if the visitors go ahead. Expect a competitive edge to this one with over 2.5 cards a reasonable shout as tackles fly in midfield and a struggling home side pushes for something.

Both Teams To Score (BTTS) Prediction

No is the call on BTTS. Exeter have not scored in four straight league games and there is nothing in their recent form to suggest that changes here. Rotherham have the tools to nick one through Mullin or Bradshaw, but Exeter finding the net feels like a stretch right now.

Corners Prediction

With Exeter needing to get forward and likely to have long spells without the ball, they could easily find themselves resorting to balls into the box late on if chasing the game. Over 8.5 corners across the ninety minutes looks reasonable, particularly if this tightens up and both sides are pushing wide to find openings.

Correct Score Prediction

A 0-1 Rotherham win is the scoreline that makes most sense here. Exeter cannot score, Rotherham are defensively organised and have a striker who knows where the net is. One goal winning it for the visitors is a logical outcome given everything the form says.

First Goalscorer Prediction

Paul Mullin is the name to be on. Four league goals already since arriving in the summer, he got on the scoresheet last weekend and is clearly growing into this level. He leads the line for a team that should see plenty of the ball and create the better chances. Mullin to open the scoring looks a solid shout.

Bet Builder Tip

A Rotherham win with Mullin getting the goal and Exeter kept off the scoresheet lines up perfectly with every strand of form pointing in the same direction.

Final Match Prediction

Exeter City 0-1 Rotherham United is where this is heading. Taylor’s former club arrive in better nick, with more goals in them and a backline that has tightened up considerably over the last few weeks. Exeter at home should give them a lift, but when you cannot score, home advantage only goes so far.

Rotherham will be patient, keep their shape, and nick it through Mullin or one of their forwards on the break. Exeter will huff and puff without finding a way through, and the Millers will take three points back up the M5. A difficult afternoon ahead for Matt Taylor against the club he knows very well.

Featured Offer

BetAhoy

Bet £10 Get a £10 Free Bet

Claim Free Bet →

Code ALLABOARD10 – Place qualifying bet within 7 days of registration (Min £10 at odds of EVS+). 2 x £5 free bets awarded once qualifying bet settles (18+). Full T&C’s Apply. #ad