Highbet
Highbet
Menu
Highbet

Penalty Betting – Which Way? The New Football Betting Market Explained

Penalty Betting – Which Way? The New Football Betting Market Explained

With the advancement of data collection in sport, it seems as though there are new betting markets popping up on bookmakers websites every week. Gone are the days of only being able to bet on the Match Result or Goalscorers. Punters can now choose between often hundreds of betting markets including the number of passes a player will make in a game, certain players to score with a specific part of their body, and one of the newest betting markets – which area of the goal a penalty will be scored in.

We’ll be taking a closer look at the ‘Which Way?’ penalty betting market, and showing you how it works, and how the bookies determine what counts as a specific area of the goal.

How ‘Which Way?’ Penalty Betting Works

Betting on penalties in a football match isn’t anything new. Bookmakers have allowed punters to bet on penalties for years with more and more betting options becoming available.

Some options for betting on penalties include:

A Penalty Kick to be Awarded – A wager on a penalty to be awarded to either team in a specific football match. This bet is valid within normal time of the game, and doesn’t include a penalty shootout.

Team to Score a Penalty – A bet on a specific team to be awarded and score a penalty within normal time of the game.

Team to Miss a Penalty – Similar to above but for the team to miss a penalty within normal time.

Method of Victory (Penalties) – This market is available in tournament fixtures where penalties are an option to determine a winner. You’re betting on the game to go to penalties and have the additional option of selecting a team to win on penalties.

In 2024, a new penalty betting market was introduced named ‘Which Way?’. With the Which Way? market, punters can place a bet on the area of the goal a penalty will be scored by a specific player.

Some examples of the Which Way? penalty market can be seen below.

which way penalty betting

It seems like a pretty simple market but one that has raised questions.

Bookmakers are under constant and increased scrutiny with some types of bets. Every week there are several punters expressing their frustration around bets that have been settled as losers because of players not registering a shot on target, or similar, when it appears they have done.

However, the responsibility of determining whether or not these statistical bets have come in or not, are generally out of the bookmakers hands. The majority of betting sites offering these type of bets use Opta data, and so it is Opta who determine the outcome, often controversially.

Opta have a set of rules that determine whether a shot was on target, whether a tackle was made, or whether a goalkeeper made a save. Some of these events are clear. However, in some instances, a shot on target, or other, can divide opinion.

So, back to betting on which way a penalty will be scored…

How The Area Of The Goal Is Decided In Penalty Betting

The main question from football punters is how to bookmakers determine whether a penalty was scored in the top left, bottom right, down the middle, or anywhere else?

The coordinates at which the ball enters the goal are adjudicated on by Opta who have the following rules:

Opta divide the goal into six equal sections:

  • Top Left
  • Bottom Left
  • Top Middle
  • Bottom Middle
  • Top Right
  • Bottom Right

A bet on ‘Middle’ includes both the Top Middle and Bottom Middle sections.

By dividing the goal into equal sections, Opta are able to determine which area the penalty was scored much easier. Of course, there will still be instances that divide opinion, but at the end of the day, the outcome will be determined by Opta.

Save and Miss, including hitting the woodwork, can also be backed in this market. If the penalty is saved or missed, any bet on the correct area of the goal will be classed as a losing bet.

Advertising Disclosure
At WhichBookie we bring you the best content and offers every day, please be aware that we do collect compensation from some of the links on this page.

Top Casinos

150% up to £150 + 75 Free Spins
Visit
100 Free Spins - No Deposit!
Visit
50 Free Spins
Visit
Stake £5 Get 50 Free Spins
Visit

Top New Bookmakers

BetMGM
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/betmgm/ ★★★★★
Visit
Tote.co.uk
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/tote-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
CasinoKings
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/online-casinos/casinokings/ ★★★★★
Visit
Bet442
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=4237684 ★★★★★
Visit
Hot Streak
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=6438606 ☆☆☆☆☆
Visit
Alfobet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=6297450 ☆☆☆☆☆
Visit
LuckyMate
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=6225952 ☆☆☆☆☆
Visit
Betmaze
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=5978437 ★★★★★
Visit
Puntit
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=5939156 ★★★★★
Visit
BetWright
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=5228168 ★★★★★
Visit
Swifty Sports
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=5645194 ☆☆☆☆☆
Visit
BetTom
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=5828818 ★★★★★
Visit
QuickBet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=5505009 ★★★★★
Visit
Highbet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/highbet/ ★★★★☆
Visit
CasinoKings
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/online-casinos/casinokings/ ★★★★★
Visit
Betano
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=4143366 ☆☆☆☆☆
Visit
MonkeyBet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=4938958 ★★★★★
Visit
JeffBet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=1651643 ☆☆☆☆☆
Visit
Star Sports
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/star-sports-review/ ★★★★★
Visit
MrLuck
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=5441347 ★★★★★
Visit
NRG.bet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=3924790 ★★★★★
Visit
talkSPORT BET
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=2018021 ★★★★★
Visit
Betrino
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=4499812 ☆☆☆☆☆
Visit
Fafabet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/fafabet/ ★★★★★
Visit
Gentleman Jim
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=3933385 ★★★★★
Visit
BetGoodwin
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=1498342 ★★★★★
Visit
BresBet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=2039219 ★★★★☆
Visit
Lottoland
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=91925 ★★★★☆
Visit
CopyBet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=2039539 ★★★★★
Visit
LiveScore Bet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/livescore-bet-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit

Top Offers

Bet £10 & Get £40 in Free Bets
Visit
Bet £10 Get £40 in Bonuses
Visit
Bet £20 & Get a £20 Free Bet
Visit
Bet £20 & Get a £20 Free Bet
Visit
Bet £20 Get £20 in Free Bets
Visit
Bet £10 Get £10 Free Bet
Visit
Bet £10 Get a £10 Free Bet
Visit
100% Bonus Up To £50
Visit
100 Free Spins - No Deposit!
Visit
Bet £10 Get £50 Free Bet
Visit
Bet £10 Get £20 Free Bet
Visit
Bet £50 & Get £25 in Free Bets
Visit
Bet £20 Get £20 in Free Bets
Visit
Bet £20 Get a £10 Free Bet
Visit
Bet £10 Get £50 in Free Bets
Visit
Bet £10 Get a £10 Free Bet
Visit
Bet £20 Get £20 in Free Bets + £10 Casino Bonus
Visit
Bet £20 Get £20 Free Bet + Up To 15% Daily Profit Boost
Visit
QPR vs Oxford United Prediction Betting Tips & Preview
Read More
Which Bookie
QPR to win
QPR vs Oxford United
Date: 01/10/25Kick-off time: 20:00Venue: Loftus Road, London Wednesday night football in the Championship, and it’s QPR welcoming Oxford United to Loftus Road. The Hoops are starting to find some form at home, while Oxford are still trying to adjust to the grind of second-tier football. QPR fans have reasons to…
Date published: September 29, 2025
Norwich vs West Brom Prediction Betting Tips & Preview
Read More
Which Bookie
Draw
Norwich vs West Brom
Date: 01/10/25Kick-off time: 19:45Venue: Carrow Road Wednesday night under the lights in the Championship, and it’s Norwich City up against West Bromwich Albion at Carrow Road. Norwich are searching for consistency after a stop-start run, while West Brom are arriving with momentum and a defence that’s starting to look the…
Date published: September 29, 2025

Top Rated Bookmakers

Highbet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/highbet/ ★★★★☆
Visit
BetMGM
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/betmgm/ ★★★★★
Visit
bet365
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/bet365-review/ ★★★★★
Visit
Coral
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/coral-bookmaker-review/ ★★★☆☆
Visit
Tote.co.uk
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/tote-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
Ladbrokes
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/ladbrokes-review/ ★★★☆☆
Visit
Betfred
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/betfred-review/ ★★★★★
Visit
William Hill
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/william-hill-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
BetUK
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/betuk-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
10bet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/10bet-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
Portsmouth vs Watford Prediction Betting Tips & Preview
Read More
Which Bookie
Draw
Portsmouth vs Watford
Date: 01/10/2025Kick-off time: 19:45Venue: Fratton Park Midweek Championship football under the lights at Fratton Park — and it feels like a big one for both sides. Portsmouth are desperate to stop the slide after a poor run of results, while Watford travel south with a little more confidence after edging…
Date published: September 29, 2025
Millwall vs Coventry Prediction Betting Tips & Preview
Read More
Which Bookie
Coventry to win
Millwall vs Coventry
Date: 01/10/25Kick-off time: 19:45Venue: The Den Wednesday night under the lights at The Den – and this one feels tasty. Millwall, stubborn and gritty at home, take on Coventry, who’ve been rattling in goals for fun. It’s defence vs attack, and you can almost feel the clash of styles already.
Date published: September 29, 2025
Corners Betting Tips
Read
Liam Johnson
Over 9.5 Corners
Everton vs West Ham
4/6

Here you'll find football corners betting tips from our expert football analyst, Liam Johnson. All of the corner predictions published here on WhichBookie are 100% free.

Date published: September 29, 2025

Best Football Bookies

bet365
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/bet365-review/ ★★★★★
Visit
10bet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/10bet-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
Ladbrokes
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/ladbrokes-review/ ★★★☆☆
Visit
Coral
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/coral-bookmaker-review/ ★★★☆☆
Visit
Virgin Bet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/virgin-bet-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
LiveScore Bet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/livescore-bet-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
Betfred
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/betfred-review/ ★★★★★
Visit
CopyBet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=2039539 ★★★★★
Visit
10bet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/10bet-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit

Best Racing Bookies

bet365
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/bet365-review/ ★★★★★
Visit
10bet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/10bet-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
Coral
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/coral-bookmaker-review/ ★★★☆☆
Visit
Ladbrokes
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/ladbrokes-review/ ★★★☆☆
Visit
Virgin Bet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/virgin-bet-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
William Hill
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/william-hill-review/ ★★★★☆
Visit
Betfred
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/bookmakers/betfred-review/ ★★★★★
Visit
CopyBet
https://www.whichbookie.co.uk/?post_type=bookmaker&p=2039539 ★★★★★
Visit
Highbet